The Perils of Protein Supplements: A Call for Vigilance and Change
- Mountaineer Satyadeep Gupta
- Jul 2, 2024
- 3 min read

As a world record-holding mountaineer, I, Satyadeep Gupta, have always emphasized the importance of genuine health and fitness. Today, I want to address a pressing issue in our fitness ecosystem: the poor standards of protein supplements.
A Long-Standing Issue
Poor standards of protein supplements isn’t something new. It always existed in our fitness ecosystem. Who is to blame? Don’t we always want everything to be cheap, don’t we always close our ears when someone says not to go for cheaper option? I firmly believe we ourselves are partners in this health-damaging trend of fake products being sold by many companies.
"We are partners in this health-damaging trend by opting for cheaper, unverified products."
The Shortcut Mentality
Another critical aspect is the shortcut mentality and the famous "chalta hai" attitude. Social media has made bodybuilding or fitness look very easy. Simple steps: join a gym, start taking supplements, and voila, you have big muscles ready to flex. But at what price? Certainly not at the cost of long-term health issues. It’s high time we quit the mentality of easy gains and start taking health very seriously.
"It’s high time we quit the mentality of easy gains and start taking health very seriously."
The FSSAI Crackdown
The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) has recently cracked down on numerous protein powder brands after a study revealed that nearly 70% of the 36 most popular protein powders in India displayed misleading information. The study found that some brands offered only half of what they claimed, with many supplements containing harmful fungal aflatoxins and pesticide residues.
"The FSSAI crackdown is a significant move towards ensuring that protein supplements are safe and accurately labeled."
This alarming situation has prompted the FSSAI to consider banning products that do not meet safety norms. The crackdown is a significant move towards ensuring that protein supplements on store shelves, e-commerce platforms, and gymnasiums are safe and accurately labeled.
The Extent of the Problem
The study, published in the journal Medicine, analyzed 36 popular protein supplements sold in India and found that nearly 70% had inaccurate protein information. Some brands offered only half of the claimed protein content, while around 14% contained harmful fungal aflatoxins and 8% had traces of pesticide residue. Clinical researchers from Rajagiri Hospital in Kerala and a US-based technology entrepreneur conducted this study, highlighting the poor quality of Indian-made herbal protein-based supplements, many of which contain liver-toxic botanicals.
"70% of protein supplements in India were found to have inaccurate protein information."
The researchers emphasised the need for stringent scrutiny, regulation, and safety studies before marketing protein-based herbal and dietary supplements. Dr. Cyriac Abby Philips, the principal investigator of the study, pointed out that despite numerous reports on organ damage due to herbal and dietary supplements, there had been no proactive and comprehensive analysis of widely used protein supplements in India.
The Government's Response
In response to these findings, the central government has acknowledged the inadequacy of existing regulations related to nutraceuticals and health supplements. A high-level committee has been formed to review the guidelines and suggest a new regulatory framework. This move aims to address the challenges in enforcing uniform regulations, especially given the interchangeable usage of the same nutrients or ingredients for pharmaceutical and nutraceutical purposes.
"The central government has acknowledged the inadequacy of existing regulations related to nutraceuticals and health supplements."
The nutraceutical market in India, estimated to reach $18 billion by 2025, requires a thorough review of its regulatory landscape to ensure the safety, efficacy, and affordability of these products. The new framework is expected to bridge the gaps in current norms and enhance consumer protection while fostering industry growth.
A Call to Action
My concerns resonate with the findings of the FSSAI study and the government's regulatory overhaul. It is imperative for consumers to be vigilant and informed about the supplements they choose. Avoiding cheap, unverified products and prioritising quality over convenience can help mitigate the risks associated with poor-quality protein supplements.
"Avoiding cheap, unverified products and prioritising quality over convenience is crucial for our health."
As the fitness industry continues to grow, the emphasis must shift towards ensuring long-term health and safety. By demanding higher standards and supporting stringent regulations, consumers and regulators can work together to eliminate harmful products from the market and promote a healthier, more transparent fitness ecosystem.
The crackdown on misleading protein supplements is a critical step towards safeguarding public health. It is time to abandon the shortcut mentality and prioritize genuine, sustainable health practices. By doing so, we can create a fitness culture that values quality, safety, and long-term well-being.
"It is time to abandon the shortcut mentality and prioritize genuine, sustainable health practices."
Thank you for addressing this important issue! As you rightly pointed out, many protein supplements on the market do not meet the necessary standards, which can be harmful to consumers. At Nutrikal, we prioritize quality, ensuring that our top private label supplement manufacturers europe meet the highest standards, so you can feel confident in what you're putting into your body. It's time to demand better, safer products for all fitness enthusiasts!